How To Keep a 100% Feedback Rating (even if you get negative feedbacks)

feedbackA few months ago, I was out sourcing retail and thrift stores with my wife. It was lunch time, so we took a break and went to one of our favorite local Mexican food restaurants. While we were waiting for our lunch to come, I received a text about a negative feedback that was just posted to my Amazon seller account. By the time lunch was done, the negative feedback had been removed, and we enjoyed the rest of the day. How was this situation fixed so quickly? More on that in a minute…

Many Amazon sellers know that winning the Buy Box is vital to their success on Amazon. If you are wanting to win the Buy Box more often, one really great way is to improve your feedback score. When Amazon sees that you are a quality seller with an amazing reputation, their Buy Box algorithm is more likely to include your inventory. About 70-80% of all Amazon sales come through the Buy Box, so it’s really important to have all your ducks in a row in order to get the Buy Box a higher percentage of time. 

Here are the methods I use to to keep a 100% feedback rating:

1. When choosing the condition of a product, round down, not up. 

Select-ConditionIf you have a book and you think its condition is somewhere between very good and good condition, round down and list the book as good. Buyers can be very picky and if they think they are ordering a book in very good condition but get a book they believe is only in good condition, you might get a negative feedback for the order. Remember, people grade items differently, so it’s best to play it safe. Plus, if someone orders an item in good condition, but then gets it and thinks it’s in very good condition, then it is much more likely you’ll get a positive feedback rating. 

2. Think twice about selling an item in acceptable condition. 

cannibalbookI almost never sell an item that I think is in acceptable condition. Just like I wrote above, different people grade items differently, and what I think might be acceptable, someone else might see as completely unacceptable. Even if you provide the buyer with the most detailed condition notes describing exactly what the item’s faults are, they probably won’t remember when they get the item days later and are more likely to post negative feedback on your account. 

3. When you get an unfair negative feedback (and you will), act quickly.  

Most of the negative feedbacks I get are product reviews, price complaints, or other unfair negative feedbacks. It’s against Amazon’s feedback policy for a buyer to leave feedback for a seller that is related to a product review or price. As soon as you get an unfair negative feedback, open up a ticket with Seller Support and ask them to remove the feedback as it violates the feedback guidelines.

When you describe your reasons to Amazon, limit the number of words you use. The longer the explanation, the more likely the Seller Support staff will ignore the bulk of your message and just deny your feedback removal request.

When communicating with Amazon, it’s always best to be concise and to the point. Most of the time, the Seller Support staff member will see your point of view and remove the unfair negative feedback. If they deny your request, your goal of feedback removal is not over. Simply open up a new ticket with Seller Support and hopefully the next Amazon staff member will understand your reasoning and remove the feedback. Feedback Removal

4. When you get a legitimate negative feedback (and you will), act quickly, apologetically, and generously. 

Maybe you forgot to put in the condition notes that the book you are selling has a lot of highlights and underlines on most of its pages… and now your customer is upset that they didn’t get a clean copy of the book. Perhaps you sent in a used music CD without testing it first, and your customer complains that the CD you sold them skips every 10 seconds. Sometimes when a buyer leaves you negative feedback, it’s deserved… but that doesn’t mean that you’re stuck with it for life.

While Seller Support probably won’t remove the feedback for you, the buyer can. When you get a negative feedback and you are in the wrong, reach out to the buyer with a friendly email. In the email, tell them that you are very sorry for the mistake you have made. Communicate to them that you have learned from your errors and you appreciate them pointing out where you went wrong. Ask them if there is anything you can do to make things up to them. Tell them that customer satisfaction is very important to you and that you want to do anything you can to make things up to them. Even go so far as to offer them a $10 Amazon gift card to make up for their inconvenience. In this email, DO NOT request that they remove the feedback; this will come later. Most likely, the buyer will accept the $10 gift card and your apology.

A few days after you send them the gift card, send them another email that communicates, once again, that customer satisfaction is very important to you. Ask them again if there is anything else you can do for them. Then, remind them that your feedback score is very important to you as a small seller on Amazon. Ask them, very politely, if they would consider removing the negative feedback only if they feel like you have made up for your error. Provide the buyer with a link or instructions to how they can easily remove (or update) your feedback score. Most of the time, the seller will remove the feedback. 

NEVER (EVER!) connect the gift card with the removal of the negative feedback. Never even talk about them in the same sentence. It is against Amazon’s policy to offer gift cards in exchange for a feedback removal, so don’t even come close to making that connection in your email communications with the buyer. 

Note: I got this Gift Card tip from Peter Valley in his book, Feedback Mastery: The Amazon Annihilation Feedback Repair SystemIf you get the book you’ll get even more details on this tip, as well as how to repair almost any other negative feedback situation. To learn more, read my Feedback Mastery book review

5. Use Feedback Genius. 

The methods that Feedback Genius uses are truly… well… genius! When I signed up for Feedback Genius, not only did my positive feedback more than double, but I was also able to more easily stop negative feedback from happening. 

fbgenius-logo-350x501Feedback Genius easily integrates with your Amazon account and automatically sends your customer an email letting them know that their order will be delivered that day (they look at the package tracking information to know this for sure). Feedback Genius then asks the customer, if they are happy with their order, to leave a five-star review on Amazon for you, the seller. Feedback Genius also tells the customer, if they have any negative issues with their order, to contact you so that you can address and fix these issues. I can’t tell you how many times I was able to avoid negative feedback since the customer knew to come to me with the problem before they left negative feedback for me on Amazon. 

A few days after the customer gets the package, if they have still not left feedback on Amazon, Feedback Genius sends a friendly reminder for the customer to leave positive feedback or to contact you if there was an issue. Again, my feedback score has more than doubled since signing up with Feedback Genius, and I’ve been able to keep a 100% feedback rating. 

My favorite feature of Feedback Genius is their text updates. Any time I get a feedback score of 3 or lower, Feedback Genius will text me and email me to notify me of the neutral/negative feedback. I can then act quickly to either ask Amazon to remove an unfair negative feedback, or I can email the buyer to start the feedback repair process. 

IMG_2383Ok, so back to the Mexican food restaurant with my wife. We were taking a lunch break from working, and while we were waiting for our food to come, I received a text from Feedback Genius about a negative feedback that was just posted to my Amazon seller account.

Since I was out to eat with my wife, I asked her if I could take a couple of minutes to deal with this situation (I wanted her to know she was my priority, not work). She said it was fine, so I spent about 90 seconds on my phone in an attempt to fix the situation.


I first noticed that the feedback in question was actually a product feedback. This particular feedback was for 2-stars and the review stated, “This item is not what I intended. Do not like it.” Seeing as this feedback was in violation of Amazon’s feedback policies, I opened up a ticket with Seller Support five minutes after the feedback was posted. I simply asked them to review and remove the feedback. I told them it was a product review and would they please remove it. About an hour later, I got the notification that the negative feedback had been removed. Soon after that, lunch was over, and we enjoyed the rest of the day sourcing. 

Without the Feedback Genius text, I probably would not have seen the negative feedback until the following morning. Who knows, I may not have seen the negative feedback for a few days. This delay would have potentially cost me sales while my feedback score was lower than it was supposed to be. 

Special Offer From Feedback Genius

FB-GeniusI spoke with Jeff from Seller Labs (creator of Feedback Genius) and he is offering my Full-Time FBA blog readers a special offer of 500 free messages for signing up for Feedback Genius. That’s 500 free messages to your buyers asking for them to leave you 5-star reviews or to contact you if there is a problem. That’s a lot of free messages, and you get them for free when you sign up for Feedback Genius. You’ll also get a 60 day free trial (that’s twice as long as their normal 30-day trial period). There is really no reason why you shouldn’t give Feedback Genius a try today. 


36 responses to “How To Keep a 100% Feedback Rating (even if you get negative feedbacks)

  1. This is great info. You are so right about keeping things considered when asking Amazon to remove negative feedback.

  2. Good job,

    I recently got a feedback “Everything came in good condition as expected.
    ” and yes to all 3 options BUT 3 stars . Not all ways can you understand

    • I’m sorry, Martin. Some customers don’t know that a 3 (neutral) feedback is actually hurts your feedback score. Maybe send the customer an email and let them know. Perhaps they will update the feedback for you.

  3. what is the cost? i went to their site and still didn’t see it..i never sign up for something if i don’t know the cost..

    • Russ, on the page where you get the free trial, there is a link to the pricing page. It’s under the “Why Sign Up?” section. The link is “Simple Pay-as-you-go Pricing” and that will explain the pricing options you can choose after your free 60 day trial.

  4. Hi Stephen,
    Thanks again for an informative article. My question is that the times that I have gotten a negative I found it almost impossible to reach the buyer. They either didn’t receive my e-mails or totally ignored them. After many unsuccesful attempts to reach the buyer many of these good tips seem to be useless. Your thoughts?

    • Gene, I’ve been in the same situation… my suggestion is to not give up. Here is what I would do:
      1. Open up tickets with Amazon asking them to remove the feedback. Keep asking different ways.
      2. Keep trying to contact the buyer. Amazon offers up different subject lines to choose from when you contact a buyer, so try them all (one at a time) to see if one will finally get through to the buyer.
      3. Make sure that the first thing you say in the email to the buyer is that you want to make things up to him/her and that customer satisfaction is your top priority. You might only have their attention for the first line, so make it count.

      Best of luck to you!

  5. Great Article! I agree completely with your suggestions and with your endorsement of Feedback Genius. It really is a great product and there is even more you can do in terms of creating custom campaigns. For example; I like included a PDF attachment with Recipes for the people that buy cooking equipment.

  6. Thanks for the post…. seems like a great service. Just signed up and looking forward to some great results.

  7. I’m fairly new and love getting those 5 Stars with feedbacks. I did get a 3 star from someone who left the comment “was as described” and nothing else. I was kind of stunned that the person got was he asked for and still only gave me 3 stars. Sheesh.

    • That stinks… another customer who doesn’t understand that a 3 is actually a score that hurts us sellers. If I were you, I’d send the customer an email and politely let them know that a 3 is seen by Amazon as a bad review… and ask them to update the feedback score. Send the the link where they can easily find where to update their feedback for you.

  8. Hi Stephen
    Great article! I just had a mentioned that negative feedback against amazons policy include price complaints and product reviews. Can you explain what you mean by “product review”?

    • When a customer buys a product on Amazon, they have the opportunity to leave feedback for the seller (you) and a review for the product they purchased. Sometimes customers get the two mixed up, so if you get a negative feedback that is actually a review of the product they purchased, you can have that removed.

  9. Thanks Stephen – Great article. We have been wondering for a while now how to handle negative reviews. This is so helpful. Quick question – when you send the customer a gift card, how do you actually send it to them? Do you email it to them? send it through the seller central system?, mail it to their shipping address?, etc??? Thanks for your help and keep up the good work.

  10. thanks Stephen, just sign up fbg !!! very helpful service

  11. Hi Stephan.
    For the customer who does not leave a review… All those orders sitting completed…
    Do you do anything outside if feedback genius
    Through seller central a d make contact , and what would that say?
    Or is that waste of time be uses feedback genius did t do it..

  12. Sorry I’ll restart:

    1. Do you send thank you through seller central if someone leaves review?
    For what strategy reason if so?
    2. Is it waste of time to send a note through seller central for someome
    Who did Not leave review if you have feedback genius?
    3. Are some reviewers working in some way for your competition, weather
    Bought organically or through a prodict discount review site
    Thx matthew

    • 1. I do not currently send a thank you after a review is posted.
      2. If you use feedback genius, then there is no need for you to an additional note to the buyer.
      3. I’m not sure what you mean in this question.

      Hope this was helpful!

  13. Stephen,
    Are you considering a feedback of ‘4’ as a 100% feedback? If not, how do coerce the customer to raising the feedback from a 4 to 5?

    Great post, btw!

    • Chad,
      Yes, Amazon considers a 4 the same as a 5… and there is no need to try and get a 4 raised up to a 5. A 100% positive feedback score is a combo of 4 and 5 star reviews for the seller, so no need to try and get the 4’s raised to a 5.

  14. Hi, Stephen. Have you noticed the change in the SC support setup? I can’t find the area for submitting a feedback dispute. I can’t find any way at all to easily do this now, except for creating a support ticket under a general heading. Any thoughts?

    • Found the link thru. Not too crazy about the changes to the support system, but, of course, there are better things to spend time and energy on. 😉

      • Yes, Seller Central just went through a “face-lift” and so some of the things look different. The tips are the same, but the steps might be a little outdated right now. I’ll work on updating them in the future.

  15. Stephen,
    I originally read this article a couple of months ago and dog eared it in my brain, if you will, because I knew I would need to refer back to this sound advice. Lo and behold, I had my opportunity this month when I received a 3 in feedback for a sale that the contents of a box did not match the listing (still not sure how that happened other than to blame the manufacturer).

    I immediately gave 100% refund and, since I was out of inventory, purchased another one and had it shipped to the client, which they received two days later.

    All of this was accompanied with emails before and after, and then a follow up asking the client to change or remove the feedback.

    Unfortunately, I never received a response nor did they change the feedback.

    At this point, would you call the client or just let it be?

    Thanks so much for the solid advice. Keep up the great work!

    • Personally, I’d let it be now. I might ask one last time. Remind them you are a small seller and your feedback is very important to you and your business. After that, I’d let it go. You’ve done all you can.

  16. Pingback: Overcoming Your Fear of an Amazon Account Suspension - Full-Time FBA

  17. Pingback: Overcoming Your Fear of Selling via FBA versus Merchant Fulfilled or eBay - Full-Time FBA

  18. Martin Haworth

    Super cool post – thanks!

  19. Pingback: 6 Steps to Take When an Item is Returned to Amazon - Full-Time FBA

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *